The Decision
Every Melbourne homeowner with cars needs weather protection for them. But should you build a carport or a garage? Here's my breakdown.
Carport Advantages
#
Lower Cost
A single carport costs $5,000-$15,000 installed. An equivalent garage costs $20,000-$40,000.#
Faster Build
Carports typically take 1-3 days to construct. Garages take 2-4 weeks.#
Simpler Permits
Most carports don't need as extensive permits as garages—especially if freestanding.#
More Open Feel
No enclosed walls means better airflow, easier access, and less visual bulk.#
Easier Council Approval
Less likely to trigger neighbourhood objections or heritage concerns.Garage Advantages
#
Complete Protection
Walls provide security and protection from dust, leaves, and extreme weather.#
Storage Space
Enclosed garages double as workshops, storage, or hobby spaces.#
Security
Lockable garages protect against theft and vandalism.#
Versatility
Can be converted to other uses (home office, gym) if needed.#
Potential Value Add
Garages often add more resale value than carports.The Melbourne Context
#
Space Constraints
Melbourne's smaller blocks often suit carports better—they feel less imposing.#
Climate
Our mild climate means car protection isn't as critical as in extreme environments. A carport handles most needs.#
Heritage Areas
In heritage-overlay suburbs, carports are often easier to get approved than garages.My Recommendation
Choose a carport if:
- Budget is limited
- You want something fast and simple
- Your block is small or narrow
- You mainly need rain/sun protection
- You need security
- You want storage/workshop space
- Resale value is a priority
- You have the budget and space
